Slideshow image over saturation

Last post 03-08-2010 15:24 by AF [Zenfolio]. 6 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (7 items)
Next
Previous
Sort Posts:
  • Karen Engel 11-18-2009 18:32

    • Top 75 Contributor
    • Joined on 03-29-2008
    • Posts: 52

    Slideshow image over saturation

    This isn't a "problem" really, in the sense of something being broken - but this section probably qualifies as the most likely to get a qualified answer.

    I've noticed (and surprised that no one else has!) the slideshows generated by ZF output images which are WAY off in color compared to how they are viewed in a normal gallery.  They are almost always way over saturated.  Nah - pretty much always.

    This issue is not ZF centric however - I have observed the exact same thing in other Flash based slideshow generators - usually to the befuddlement of their "tech support" people when the issue is raised.

    I've already resigned myself to the fact that there is no likely magic bullet to fix this - and I certainly cannot do special post production versions of all my images to please slideshow generators.  However, I AM wondering if there is someone out there who will acknowledge the issue and maybe explain why this happens?

    Best guess - Some kind of limitation in super compacted Flash routines for web, and possible compression algorithms it imposes in order to pull off the "magic". It would just be nice to hear "yes, we know" and why.

    For those that don't think this exists, please compare a normal gallery image from here -

    http://www.karenengel.com/p541291614/h31415094#h31415094

    To a ZF generated slideshow image from here -

    http://www.karenengelphotography.com/connections/slideshow7.html

    Karen Engel Photography
    http://www.karenengelphotography.com
  • AF [Zenfolio] 11-19-2009 8:58 In reply to

    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 02-29-2008
    • San Francisco Bay Area, California
    • Posts: 721

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    The most likely cause for the difference in colors is that your browser (Firefox or Safari) recognizes the sRGB color profile that is embedded in the image and does proper color management, while Flash ignores the color profile and does no color management.

    By the way, Internet Explorer users won't see any difference as this browser is not color-aware and would show the same colors as Flash.

    -- AF [Zenfolio]
  • Karen Engel 11-19-2009 12:34 In reply to

    • Top 75 Contributor
    • Joined on 03-29-2008
    • Posts: 52

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    Thank you - that makes perfect sense!  I did a little more searching with CMS in mind and found an article here - 

    http://blogs.adobe.com/jnack/2008/10/get_better_color_through_fp10.html

    Also some mention of "Flex" - something new in Flash to be released....so maybe in the future this will be less problematic.

    Anyway, that's the answer - much appreciated.

    Karen Engel Photography
    http://www.karenengelphotography.com
  • alexcel 02-08-2010 14:05 In reply to

    • Top 500 Contributor
    • Joined on 04-12-2008
    • Posts: 8

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    Hi

    Yes, I have also found this problem with my Dell 2408WFP wide gamut monitor.

    Will zenfolio correct color managment in flash? it can be done using the technique described by john nack

    http://blogs.adobe.com/jnack/2008/10/get_better_color_through_fp10.html

    Any suggestion or release plan from zenfolio would be greatly appreciated.

     

    Thx.

     

  • AF [Zenfolio] 02-08-2010 14:07 In reply to

    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 02-29-2008
    • San Francisco Bay Area, California
    • Posts: 721

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    The plan is to fix it in the next release (early March). 

    -- AF [Zenfolio]
  • alexcel 03-08-2010 15:08 In reply to

    • Top 500 Contributor
    • Joined on 04-12-2008
    • Posts: 8

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    I think the problem has not been fixed.

    Any info on this subject??

     

    Thx.

  • AF [Zenfolio] 03-08-2010 15:24 In reply to

    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 02-29-2008
    • San Francisco Bay Area, California
    • Posts: 721

    Re: Slideshow image over saturation

    -- AF [Zenfolio]
Page 1 of 1 (7 items)