Aaron, I agree 100%. I am in even worse of a situation. I slaved away for months to build my site and make it as user-friendly as the ZF software would allow, but NOT ONE ORDER. Even with my word-of-mouth visitors no one has bought a thing, nor even had the courtesy to email me with any complaints. ZF, of course, tells me they can find nothing on my site that would deter sales. Really? Even when I spent hours putting a price list of available sizes in the Caption area for every expanded picture among my 700 images, so they would know what to expect to pay before going to the cart, still no sales.
As I have not enabled Google Analytics on my site (because of the customer privacy concerns I read about), I have no way of telling what page they exited out of. Betcha they all bailed at the cart. And from what you and others have blogged, I can now see why! Who would buy a 2.00 print, then get jacked with 6.45, plus 9.5% Cal. Sales tax? Hell, I actually SOLD a number of prints when I shopped them person to person doing my own fulfillment (I took my jpeg to the lab, had it printed and physically handed it to my customer.) I'd hate to have to trash my whole site's work just because I can't sell with MPix's high shipping costs. Beginning to think I should abandon e-commerce altogether, and just sell person to person, where at least I was selling and making a decent profit to boot. What good is high traffic (no I haven't achieved that yet) but a 0% conversion rate? I feel your pain.
Could you have a look at my site at www.gonyeaneimages.zenfolio.com and see if there is some sales deterrent that is my fault? I would greatly appreciate it, and I hope you succeed in your online business.
Lynne